Planning Your First Screenshot: Winning the Install with One Image
You can put real care into every screenshot in your set, and most people scrolling a list will still only see the first one. How many screenshots show up in search results or featured lists, and at what size, varies by store, device and orientation, and it changes from time to time. What doesn't change is that the first image is the one people see first. Even on screens that show several at once, the eye lands on the first image, and the ones after it only get swiped through by people the first image has already stopped.
This post assumes exactly that situation — someone deciding from the first image alone — and walks through how to decide what goes on it. Polishing caption copy is covered in How to Write Screenshot Captions That Actually Convert, and the craft of catching a good moment in How to Capture Great Game Screenshots, so here we focus on the step before both: choosing the message and the scene.
What State Is the Viewer In?
Someone swiping through screenshots on your detail page and someone skimming search results are looking at your image under completely different conditions. Before planning the first image, picture the second person as concretely as you can — it narrows down what the image actually has to do.
- They see it small — the image takes up only part of the screen, so small text and fine UI detail barely register.
- They see it next to competitors — similar games in the same genre sit directly above and below it.
- They see it in passing — if there's no reason to stop scrolling, they move straight on to the next item.
- They've already seen the name and icon — the first image doesn't need to repeat what those two have already said.
Under these conditions there isn't much a first image can accomplish. Instead of explaining everything that's fun about the game, it's enough to answer one question — "what is this, and is it for me?" — well enough to make a thumb stop. The rest of the persuasion belongs to the second image onward and to the detail page.
Three Questions for Narrowing Down to One Message
The hard part of planning a first image isn't finding a message — it's cutting down to one. That's why it's easier to get plenty of candidates on the table and filter them. Write at least five one-sentence descriptions of your game or app, then ask three things about each one.
- Does it apply just as well to competitors? If the sentence fits most games in the genre, it has no power to set you apart in a list.
- Can it be shown in a single picture? A message that only makes sense once you've read the caption won't come across at small sizes.
- Does it connect to what the viewer came looking for? People only stop when it lines up with what they wanted from browsing that genre in the first place.
Take a hypothetical farm management game. Its candidates might be scored like this.
| Candidate Message | Distinct from Competitors | Works as a Picture | Matches Expectations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raise cute animals | Weak | Easy | Strong |
| Scenery changes with the seasons | Medium | Medium | Medium |
| Lay out your fields any way you like | Strong | Easy | Strong |
| Play in short sessions | Medium | Hard | Medium |
"Lay out your fields any way you like" passes all three questions and becomes the first-image message. The rejected candidates don't have to be thrown away. A strength that's hard to show in a picture, like "play in short sessions," can go into the description or into the caption on a later screenshot.
Three Types of First Image: Core Play, Identity, Outcome
Once the message is settled, choose what kind of scene will carry it. Most first images fall into one of three types, and each suits different games and apps and comes with its own trap.
| Type | What It Shows | Good Fit For | Watch Out For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core play | The screen at the moment of actually playing | Puzzle and action games whose rules are clear from one screen; games where the control scheme is the differentiator | If the screen looks like the genre average, it disappears among competitors |
| Identity | A scene that compresses the world, protagonist or mood | Games whose strength is story, characters or art; apps with a distinctive concept | Doesn't convey what you actually do. If the image is far from the real screen, it leads to disappointment after install |
| Outcome | The finished state the user ends up with | Decorating and management games; editing, organizing and journaling apps | The process is missing, so "how?" goes unanswered. If it's beyond what an ordinary user could make, it reads as exaggeration |
For the farm game above, the message is about decorating, so the outcome type — a full view of a lovingly arranged farm — is the natural fit. Had the message been "cute animals," the identity type would have been right. Don't pick a type first and force the message into it; let the message decide the type and there's less to agonize over. If you want to blend two types, make one the star and keep the other to a small element in a corner.
Comparing Candidate Scenes Side by Side
With the type settled, prepare three to five actual scene candidates. Don't choose in your head — scale the captures down to the same size and lay them out on one screen, because that's the only way the differences show. Check the following five things in order.
- What survives when it's shrunk? Scenes where the protagonist or key object keeps its shape have the advantage.
- Does the message show with the caption covered? "A decorated farm" should read without any text at all.
- Does it look like the same game as the icon? When the first image carries over the icon's colors and characters, the two read as one unit in a list.
- Can players reach this scene quickly? A late-game scene that takes hours to reach opens a gap between expectation and the actual experience.
- Does it stand out among competitors? Paste several first images from similar games onto one board and drop your candidate in among them. If it takes you a moment to find your own, choose again.
A scene that wins on every point is rare. Realistically, weight 1 and 2 most heavily and use 4 as a disqualifier.
What to Cut from the First Image
The elements that blur a first image's focus usually come from the urge to squeeze in "just one more thing." The following show up in first images all the time, and they compete with the message.
| Cut This | Problem | Do This Instead |
|---|---|---|
| A collage of several screens stitched together | Nothing reads at small sizes | One strongest screen, shown large |
| A caption that lists features | Takes long to read and dilutes the point | Keep one line of message; push features to later images |
| A big logo | The name is already visible in the list, so it wastes space | Make it small or leave it out |
| Several badges and award blurbs | Cover the scene and split attention | One at most, if truly needed, somewhere it doesn't hide the scene |
| Tutorial or menu screens | Can't show what's fun | The screen at the moment the message is actually happening |
Back to the farm game: a first image with a four-screen collage under the caption "Farming, fishing, cooking, and a whole village!" is far less legible at small sizes than a single view of a decorated farm with the line "A farm that's yours to design." Fishing and cooking belong to later images.
What to Check Once You've Decided
When a draft of the first image is ready, run these checks before refining the design.
- Put the first image next to the icon and name, and view it at a small size close to the real list.
- Show it briefly to someone who doesn't know the game and ask them to say, in one sentence, what kind of game it seems to be. If that sentence is close to the message you chose, it passes.
- Place the second image beside it and check that it picks up what the first one promised. If the first image talks about decorating and the second is about combat, the thread breaks.
- If you're still left with two candidates at the end, don't force a choice — keep both as something to compare after launch.
For that last step, it helps to have several versions that keep the same layout and change only the scene and caption. StoreShot is free with no sign-up, and it lets you swap just the caption and image within one template to turn out several first-image candidates quickly. For comparing candidates against real visitor behavior after launch, see Validating Screenshot Conversion with Google Play Store Listing Experiments.
Wrapping Up
Planning a first image is closer to selection than to design. Picture the person who sees it small, next to competitors and in passing; filter your candidate messages through the three questions until one remains; then choose the type and scene that fit that message by comparing them side by side. When the first image says one thing clearly, every image after it can concentrate on backing that one thing up.